Amendment to tax regulation on foreign suppliers proposed
Many foreign suppliers take advantage of the double tax agreements to avoid tax obligations. Photo cafef.vn |
HÀ NỘI — The Government has recently proposed to amend a regulation of the Law on Tax Administration to better manage tax for foreign suppliers.
Under the proposal, the Government plans to clear up rules on foreign businesses which have argued that they do not have a fixed base in Việt Nam and are demanding huge tax refunds.
Under the current Clause 4, Article 42 of the law, for e-commerce business, digital-based business and other services of foreign suppliers ‘without having a permanent establishment’ in Việt Nam, the foreign suppliers are directly obliged to or authorise tax registration, tax declaration and tax payment in Việt Nam.
The ministry proposes to remove the phrase ‘without having a permanent establishment in Việt Nam’ in Clause 4, Article 42. The amendment will create many changes in the way that Việt Nam imposes tax on foreign suppliers.
Many foreign suppliers such as Meta, Google and Netflix are requesting Việt Nam’s tax authorities to refund the corporate income tax they paid because they do not have a permanent establishment in Việt Nam.
The amount of tax requested to be refunded is up to thousands of billions of Vietnamese đồng.
Many experts agreed with the Government’s proposal, saying that to ensure fairness among taxpayers as well as the responsibility of foreign suppliers to fulfil their tax obligations to the Vietnamese state, the phrase ‘without having a permanent establishment in Việt Nam’ should be removed.
According to lawyer Nguyễn Duy Nguyên, General Director of Hoàng Giao Law Firm, Clause 4, Article 42 stipulates the principles of tax declaration and calculation for e-commerce business, digital-based business and other services that are performed by foreign suppliers without having a permanent establishment in Việt Nam.
Thus, foreign suppliers with a permanent establishment in Việt Nam will not be directly or authorised to register for tax, declare tax and pay tax in Việt Nam. In this case, the foreign suppliers have the right to only perform the obligation to pay corporate income tax on the portion of profits allocated to permanent establishments according to the provisions of the Law on Corporate Income Tax and the Double Taxation Avoidance Agreement.
Meanwhile, according to the provisions of the Law on Value Added Tax and the Law on Corporate Income Tax, when foreign suppliers conduct e-commerce business, digital-based business and other services in Việt Nam, they are subject to corporate income tax and value added tax. This makes it difficult to collect taxes from foreign e-commerce service providers, such as in the case of online booking service providers Booking and Agoda.
“In my opinion, to create fairness among taxpayers and ensure adequate revenue for e-commerce activities, it is necessary to remove the phrase ‘without having a permanent establishment in Việt Nam’ under Clause 4, Article 42 on tax declaration and calculation principles,” Nguyên said.
The General Department of Taxation (GDT) also believes that retaining the phrase ‘without having permanent establishment’ may no longer be suitable for the current e-commerce business. Online transactions do not require a physical presence such as office, factory or staff in Việt Nam, so determining a permanent establishment becomes more complicated.
According to the GDT, double tax avoidance agreements (DTAs) were signed many years ago, but mainly applied to traditional business activities with a physical presence. Meanwhile, e-commerce business operates mainly in cyberspace, without a physical presence, which causes the application of current tax regulations to become inappropriate.
Economist Dr. Đinh Trọng Thịnh also said the application of DTAs was causing difficulties in determining tax liability. Many foreign suppliers took advantage of the DTAs to avoid tax obligations. This was a concern, especially when corporate income tax from e-commerce transactions could become an important source of revenue for the national budget in the future.
Therefore, Thịnh believes amending the provisions in Clause 4, Article 42 will open up opportunities for tax authorities to manage taxes more effectively. If the phrase ‘without having a permanent establishment’ is removed, tax authorities will have a legal basis to require foreign suppliers doing business in Việt Nam to fulfil tax obligations, regardless of whether they have a permanent establishment in the country or not.
The removal of the phrase ‘without having a permanent establishment’ in the law is a necessary step in reforming the tax system in Việt Nam. This not only ensures the State's right to collect taxes but also creates a clear legal framework for foreign suppliers operating e-commerce businesses in Việt Nam.
See also
VAT tax reduction should continue until mid-2025: Ministry
17:15 | 21/11/2024 Policy
NA deputies scrutinise investment policy for North-South high-speed railway project
08:54 | 21/11/2024 Policy
Developing relations with China is Vietnam’s top priority: Deputy PM
08:40 | 20/11/2024 Policy
Vietnam pledges to make more contributions to APEC cooperation
09:46 | 17/11/2024 Policy
Amending the Law on Electricity to unlock resources for energy security and net zero emissions
10:04 | 16/11/2024 Policy
Ambassador highlights importance of PM Phạm Minh Chính’s Brazil trip
14:19 | 15/11/2024 Policy
See more news
PM urged parliament to pass legislation to ensure sufficient electricity, restart nuclear projects
09:47 | 13/11/2024 Policy
New policy drafted to help non-bank credit institutions develop further
17:13 | 12/11/2024 Policy
Việt Nam to stiffen regulations on violating social network platforms
16:23 | 12/11/2024 Policy
Party leader of Việt Nam holds phone talks with President-elect of US
08:55 | 12/11/2024 Policy
Vietnam affirms active, responsible role in APEC
15:56 | 11/11/2024 Policy
Additional policies on advertising by influencers proposed for the Advertising Law
17:25 | 09/11/2024 Policy
Prime Minister urges promotion of new growth drivers
17:10 | 09/11/2024 Policy
New regulations on mergers, consolidation of credit institutions proposed
09:25 | 08/11/2024 Policy
Vietnam gives top priority to relations with China: PM
16:43 | 07/11/2024 Policy
PM puts forth proposals to develop new-generation GMS economic corridors
14:59 | 07/11/2024 Policy
VAT tax reduction should continue until mid-2025: Ministry
17:15 | 21/11/2024 Policy
Top legislator starts official visit to Cambodia
17:09 | 21/11/2024 News and Events
Việt Nam and Malaysia upgrade relationship to Comprehensive Strategic Partnership level
17:01 | 21/11/2024 Cooperation
Hà Nội prepares for temperature drop as cold front approaches
16:56 | 21/11/2024 Environment
First Vietnam Dialogue opens new avenues for Vietnam-Germany financial cooperation
16:18 | 21/11/2024 Cooperation
Multimedia
Vietnam - Malaysia Strategic Partnership
10:54 | 21/11/2024 Infographic
Vietnam, Dominican Republic strengthening cooperation
08:45 | 20/11/2024 Infographic
Vietnam - Brazil strategic partnership
10:26 | 19/11/2024 Infographic
Nhon - Hanoi Station elevated urban railway comes into operation
09:04 | 18/11/2024 Infographic
Key facts on G20 and Vietnam's participation
09:42 | 17/11/2024 Infographic
VAT tax reduction should continue until mid-2025: Ministry
17:15 | 21/11/2024 Policy
NA deputies scrutinise investment policy for North-South high-speed railway project
08:54 | 21/11/2024 Policy
Developing relations with China is Vietnam’s top priority: Deputy PM
08:40 | 20/11/2024 Policy
Vietnam pledges to make more contributions to APEC cooperation
09:46 | 17/11/2024 Policy
Tra fish sector aiming for production, processing greening for sustainable development
15:38 | 20/11/2024 Industry
Solutions discussed to ensure coal supply for electricity generation in 2025
16:24 | 19/11/2024 Energy
Garment industry targets 47-48 billion USD in export turnover next year
16:16 | 19/11/2024 Industry
Residents support restarting Ninh Thuận Nuclear Project, call for clear roadmap
14:46 | 18/11/2024 Energy
Workshop seeks ways to attract Japan’s green investment to Vietnam
09:43 | 20/11/2024 Investment
Government approves investment policy to build Cam Lien Industrial Park in Quang Binh
16:57 | 18/11/2024 Investment
Disbursement of public investment must be accelerated: Deputy PM
12:17 | 17/11/2024 Investment
LG plans to pour further US$1 billion investment into Vietnam
10:42 | 16/11/2024 Investment
HDBank wins three awards at Vietnam Listed Company Awards 2024
10:53 | 21/11/2024 Finance-Banking
VIB, Flywire partner to streamline cross-border payments for students from Vietnam
16:46 | 18/11/2024 Finance-Banking
Vietcombank issues 2 trillion VND worth of green bonds for first time
18:55 | 16/11/2024 Finance-Banking
UK stands ready to help Vietnam build international financial hub
17:13 | 13/11/2024 Finance-Banking
Hà Nội prepares for temperature drop as cold front approaches
16:56 | 21/11/2024 Environment
Hundreds of damaged irrigation reservoirs need repairing
09:02 | 20/11/2024 Environment
Greening e-commerce crucial for sustainable development
10:47 | 18/11/2024 Environment
National Environmental Protection Plan ensures high quality living environment
08:59 | 18/11/2024 Environment
People, community at heart of digital transformation: Deputy PM
09:26 | 21/11/2024 Science - Technology
AI is core technology of 4th Industrial Revolution: Minister
11:19 | 20/11/2024 Science - Technology
Global scientific luminaries to gather at VinFuture sci-tech week
11:08 | 19/11/2024 Science - Technology
Hà Nội to host 2024 e-commerce and digital economy forum on November 21
17:23 | 17/11/2024 Science - Technology
Việt Nam-UK Institute plans for an international university
09:14 | 21/11/2024 Society
Hanoi aims to become a smart city by 2030
09:13 | 21/11/2024 Metropolis
Huế Central Hospital boosts international cooperation to become global health hub
16:30 | 20/11/2024 Society
Hà Nội hospital partners with UK charity to provide surgeries for children with facial deformities
16:03 | 20/11/2024 Society
VN takes part in food and beverage fair in Chicago
09:45 | 20/11/2024 Vietnamese Brands
Hòa Bình honey awaits reactions from UK
10:41 | 19/11/2024 Vietnamese Brands
Post-Typhoon Yagi trade networking event starts in Hải Dương
10:04 | 19/11/2024 Vietnamese Brands
Hòa Bình exports honey and pearl onions to UK
10:17 | 16/11/2024 Vietnamese Brands
Bac Ninh Province: Dong Ho folk painting needs urgent safeguarding
15:04 | 20/11/2024 Culture
Vietnamese designers tell stories of culture at Fashion Week
10:14 | 20/11/2024 Culture
Creative City promotes socio-economic development, says expert
09:59 | 20/11/2024 Lifestyle
Five Vietnamese creations listed among the world’s 100 best-rated dishes with coconut
10:54 | 19/11/2024 Culture
Blooming buckwheat flowers on Ha Giang roads
14:54 | 21/11/2024 Tourism
Folk cultural festival on Côn Đảo Island attracts tourists
10:07 | 20/11/2024 Tourism
Tra Que named among world’s best tourism villages in 2024
11:20 | 18/11/2024 Tourism
Quảng Ninh to attract more foreign tourists by year-end
16:52 | 14/11/2024 Tourism